The Wild West turned lawmen, outlaws and cowboys into legends, in books and on the screen. It did the same for the guns they carried. Like the men themselves, those guns have picked up an aura of mystery that has only grown over the years.
Doc Holliday is a good example. Plenty of guns have been called “Doc Holliday’s gun,” but very few can be traced to him. Here we sort what is documented from what is legend, and look at the guns Val Kilmer carried as Doc in the movie Tombstone.
The Legend of Doc Holliday
John Henry “Doc” Holliday was a dentist by profession, but he became far better known for his gambling and his gun than for his dentistry. In Tombstone, Arizona, he was a close friend of the Earp brothers, a friendship that put him in the gunfight at the O.K. Corral against the Cowboys, one of the most famous events of the American frontier.
Holliday graduated from the Pennsylvania College of Dental Surgery. He was not the most popular man in town. He had a reputation as a gambler, a heavy drinker and a gunfighter. But he was admired for his courage and his loyalty to his friend Wyatt Earp, and he made his name in the West despite suffering from tuberculosis. Read more in our Doc Holliday biography.
How Fast Was Doc Holliday with a Gun?
In Stuart Lake’s 1931 biography of Wyatt Earp, Wyatt calls Doc “the most skillful gambler and nerviest, speediest, deadliest man with a six-gun I ever knew.” Lake’s book is not always reliable, but that line, quoted in HistoryNet’s Doc Holliday profile and many other places, did a lot to build Doc’s reputation.
Many stories of Doc’s gunfights have to be taken with a grain of salt. What is clear is that he was involved in several shootings, from wounding saloon owner Milt Joyce in Tombstone in 1880 to the O.K. Corral in 1881 and a showdown with Billy Allen in Leadville, Colorado, in 1884.
The Only Documented Doc Holliday Gun: an 1851 Navy Colt
According to firearms historian Lee A. Silva, writing in Wild West magazine, only one revolver can be absolutely documented as Doc’s: a cap-and-ball Model 1851 Navy Colt with the standard 7½-inch barrel, serial number 198418, with its original holster. His uncle, Dr. John Stiles Holliday, gave it to him after the Civil War. After Doc died in 1887 it was kept in a family safe-deposit box until the family sold it in the 20th century.1 Holliday family descendant Karen Holliday Tanner writes that Doc carried it until about 1874, when cartridge revolvers were replacing cap-and-ball guns.1

What Guns Did Doc Holliday Use in Real Life?
A Nickel-Plated “Self-Cocker”
When Doc shot Milt Joyce and his bartender at the Oriental Saloon on October 10, 1880, he used a borrowed revolver described as a “self-cocker,” a double-action gun that fires with a squeeze of the trigger. At the O.K. Corral a year later, several witnesses said Doc used a nickel-plated revolver. In Lake’s biography, Wyatt describes Doc’s “nickel-plated Colt’s” as his favorite weapon for years.1
Historians have often taken this to mean a nickel-plated Colt Model 1877, the double-action Colt sold as the Lightning in .38 caliber and the Thunderer in .41. For the 1884 Leadville shooting, Karen Holliday Tanner believes Doc carried a .41-caliber Lightning/Thunderer, though another newspaper said it was a short-barreled single-action Colt .44. As Silva puts it, no particular Colt is definitely documented as Doc’s, and other double-action revolvers on the market could have been his.1

The Colt Single Action Army of 1873, the famous “Peacemaker,” was the standard sidearm of the era, and a single-action Colt may also have been among Doc’s guns. But no Peacemaker has been documented as his.

The Coach Gun at the O.K. Corral
The only shotgun Doc definitely used is the short double-barreled coach gun that Virgil Earp took from the Wells Fargo office and handed to Doc on the way to the fight. Doc used it to kill Tom McLaury in the street fight. That gun disappeared and has never turned up.1 Silva doubts that Doc, frail from tuberculosis, ever regularly carried a shotgun of his own.1
The Remington Derringer from Kate
An 1866 Remington derringer with “To Doc from Kate” on the handle is believed to be one of the few things in Doc’s room at the Hotel Glenwood when he died there on November 8, 1887. Kate was his common-law wife, “Big Nose” Kate. Hotel bartender William G. Wells is said to have received the gun as partial payment for Doc’s funeral, and it stayed in his family until 1968. In 2017 the Glenwood Springs Historical Society bought it after a Holliday expert reviewed its paperwork and declared it real.
The Doc’s Other Weapon: Knives
Doc also carried a knife. According to historian Gary Roberts, when Doc left Valdosta, Georgia, in 1873 he took a fighting knife belonging to his cousin Tom McKey, made from a meat cleaver; Tom called it the “Hell Bitch.”1 A San Francisco bowie knife made by Michael Price is also claimed to have been Doc’s, supposedly given to a miner near Bisbee, but that story is unproven. The famous tale of Doc knifing a gambler named Ed Bailey at Fort Griffin, Texas, comes from Lake’s book and has little evidence behind it.1
What Gun Did Doc Holliday Use in the Movie Tombstone?
In the 1993 film Tombstone, Doc Holliday was played by Val Kilmer. His performance made Doc the star of the movie for many fans: sarcastic, sick and dangerous, with his violence controlled and focused through the barrel of a gun.
Kilmer’s Doc carries an ivory-gripped, nickel-plated Colt Model 1877 Lightning in a shoulder holster as his first weapon, and an ivory-gripped Colt Single Action Army in a hip holster.1 Those two guns, along with the Navy Colt and the derringer, are the “Doc Holliday guns” that collectors most often buy as replicas.
Where Are Doc Holliday’s Guns Now?
The derringer is the centerpiece of the Doc Holliday Collection in Glenwood Springs, Colorado, a satellite of the Glenwood Springs Historical Society’s Frontier Museum. It sits on the site of the Hotel Glenwood where Doc died, and it also shows his pocket watch, photos and drawings of Doc, and the stone walls that survived the 1945 fire that destroyed the hotel.
Doc Holliday died in Glenwood Springs at 36 and is buried in the town’s Linwood Cemetery, though the exact spot is unknown. Very much like his guns, we know where Doc has been, but not exactly where he is now.
The Myth of the O.K. Corral Lives On
Here’s the scene in Tombstone where Virgil hands Doc the coach gun before the fight.

The myth of Wyatt Earp and Doc Holliday at the O.K. Corral has grown beyond the facts. What remains true is that the guns these men used helped define the image of the gunslinger and the lawman on the American frontier.
References
1 Silva, L.A. (2014, October). What type of weapon did Doc Holliday carry? Wild West. Retrieved from https://www.historynet.com/course-holliday-used-guns-occasion-knives/


4 comments
There is a picture of Val Kilmer as Doc Holiday in the Hampton Inn Lobby in DODGE CITY, KANSAS. Awesome photo and signed by Val Kilmer
I met Doc Holliday grandson of the original in Kingman, Arizona. He was a cashier at Safeway is I D said Doc Holliday. He and his wife invited us my wife and I to dinner. Steve Robinett
as far as I am concerned go with the legend it makes foe better reading
You need to research your weapons a little better. The 1873 colt was the peacemaker, equalizer. Frontier was actually one of the models made. The barrels were 7 1/2 as asked for by the military. The 1855 colt navy was a 36 caliber pistol. Also it is a 1860 henry not 62. They were not mass produced till 62 but that is not the model. They were no too cumbersome to use on horseback since they were a calvary weapon.