- Cowhand, miner and Cowboy
- Trouble with the law: the killing of James Hickey
- Billy Claiborne at the Gunfight at the O.K. Corral
- Calling himself “Billy the Kid”
- Horse thief? Not according to him
- The death of Billy Claiborne at the hand of Buckskin Frank
- Why did Billy Claiborne go after Leslie?
- Who played Billy Claiborne in the 1993 movie Tombstone?
Billy Claiborne was born in Yazoo County, in west-central Mississippi, on October 21, 1860. Not much is known about his youth, though some say he was a teen with a chip on his shoulder. He turned up in Arizona around 1879, working for John Slaughter as a cowhand.
He is remembered for a killing in Charleston, for running from the Gunfight at the O.K. Corral, for calling himself “Billy the Kid,” and for the drunken confrontation with Buckskin Frank Leslie that ended his life in 1882.

Cowhand, miner and Cowboy
Claiborne helped John Slaughter drive cattle from Texas to Arizona Territory in 1879. Around Tombstone he later worked in the mines: on the amalgamator at the mills in Charleston, and driving a slag cart at the Neptune Mining Company smelter in Hereford.

Billy Claiborne is best known for his association with the Cochise County Cowboys. He likely met the Clantons and McLaurys while working as a drover for Slaughter, or while working in Charleston, where both families, and particularly the Clantons, spent time. Claiborne was known as a friend of Billy Clanton’s.

Trouble with the law: the killing of James Hickey
In early October 1881, Billy was in a Charleston saloon when he shot and killed James Hickey. Both men had been drinking heavily, and Hickey was said to be a mean sort.
Hickey had already been mouthing off when he noticed Billy. Billy reportedly accused him of following him and told him to stop or he’d shoot. Billy pulled his pistol. Hickey turned toward him, and Billy fired, hitting Hickey below the left eye. He fell dead.

On Friday afternoon James Hickey was shot and killed in Charleston, Cachise county, by William Clayborn, “The Kid,” in a drunken quarrel. Clayborn was arrested and taken to Tombstone.
The trial opened in late November. On the first two court days, so many jurors failed to show up that it couldn’t proceed. When the jury finally sat, it asked to convict on a lesser degree of murder. The judge refused, the jury could not agree, and he declared a mistrial.
The retrial finally took place in May 1882. After 72 hours of deliberation, the jury found him not guilty.

The jury in the Claiborne murder case, at Tombstone after being out seventy-two hours, come into court Saturday with a verdict of “Not Guilty.”
Billy Claiborne at the Gunfight at the O.K. Corral
October 26, 1881, is an infamous day in Tombstone history. Billy Claiborne was with Tom and Frank McLaury and Ike and Billy Clanton in the vacant lot near the O.K. Corral when the Earps and Doc Holliday arrived. When the shooting started, the unarmed Billy ran out the back of the lot. With the Hickey trial ahead of him, he probably wanted no more trouble.
Calling himself “Billy the Kid”
If imitation is the sincerest form of flattery, Billy Claiborne sure flattered William Bonney, the original Kid.
After William “Billy the Kid” Bonney was killed in July 1881, Claiborne demanded that others call him “Billy the Kid.” He reportedly killed one to three men who refused. Claiborne was a heavy drinker and a hothead, and he became friends with Ike and Billy Clanton and with Tom and Frank McLaury.
Horse thief? Not according to him
“Billy the Kid” Claiborne was soon in hot water again. Pete Spence was missing some horses, and the Epitaph reported that Billy was the suspect. As the story unfolded, the Epitaph printed a July 1 clarification that cleared “The Kid.”
Apparently Claiborne knew who the thieves were. Pete Spence ran with the same Cowboy crowd as Billy, after all. So the Kid set out after them, got Pete’s stock back and was bringing it home.

Much injustice was done Billy Claiborne by the report circulated that he had ran off some stock belonging to Pete Spence. It now appears that he followed the Mexicans who stole the stock, from Tuesday morning until the following Thursday night, making over 250 miles in that length of time, but managed to secure the horses. The “Kid” naturally felt indignant that such a report should get abroad, especially as he was in a dead run after the thieves, and without food for three days.
The death of Billy Claiborne at the hand of Buckskin Frank

Early on Tuesday, November 14, 1882, Buckskin Frank Leslie was at the Oriental Saloon. The Kid came in, walked right up to Frank and started bad-mouthing him with vile language. Frank tried to calm him. When that didn’t work, he walked him outside, with Billy threatening, “I’ll get even on you.”
Soon a man came into the Oriental to tell Frank that someone was waiting outside for him. Then another told him Claiborne was on Allen Street with a rifle, asking for Frank. Frank went outside and saw Billy by a fruit stand.
Leslie said, “Billy, don’t shoot…” But Billy fired, and then Frank did. Billy was hit and said, “Don’t shoot again, I am killed.”
Buckskin Frank was arrested by Officer Coyle. Before long Billy was dead. After hearing the witnesses, the coroner’s jury ruled the shooting self-defense.
Why did Billy Claiborne go after Leslie?

What drove Billy to try to kill Buckskin Frank Leslie? There are hints in the testimony, and plenty of theories.
One coroner’s witness, Otto Johnson, said Billy told him just before the shooting, “I don’t allow any man to spit on me… and if he don’t come out I will go in and make him fight.” Johnson said Billy told him that man was Leslie.
Another witness, William Hush, quoted Billy straight out: “I am going to kill Frank Leslie,” with no further explanation. When Hush tried to talk him out of it, Billy threatened him.
Oriental bartender E.H. Dean said Billy butted into Frank’s conversation with friends by making snide political remarks. Frank told him to go away, since they weren’t even talking politics. Billy said he wouldn’t, so Frank took him out by the collar, and Billy said “he would allow no man to handle him in a manner of that kind.”
Finally there’s the theory behind his last words: that it was revenge, because Billy believed Buckskin Frank Leslie had killed Johnny Ringo. Dr. G.C. Willis gave this testimony:

He was not wholly conscious. He said he was a murdering son of a b—- to shoot a man in the back. I was examining the back when he make that remark. I think he received the would in front.
Who played Billy Claiborne in the 1993 movie Tombstone?
So who is the Wyatt Earp you see flashing by in the credits of Tombstone? Wyatt Earp III was born Glen Wyatt Earp on October 2, 1962, in Stillwater, Oklahoma. He is an actor known for Tombstone (1993), Sordid Lives: The Series (2008) and Angel Fire (1992), and he has his own website.

He is a relative of the historical Wyatt Earp, though not a direct descendant, since Earp had no children. It’s kind of funny that he got to play Billy Claiborne opposite Kurt Russell, who plays his namesake Wyatt Earp in the movie. At least I got a kick out of it.


No comments yet