Tombstone, Arizona · Open daily, no entry fee · Most shops close around 5 p.m.Contact
Tombstone Travel Tips
Carleton Watkins photograph of the open ore quarry at the Tough Nut mine with part of Tombstone and the Dragoon Mountains behind, 1880
Wild West History

Tombstone Mining

How silver built Tombstone: Brunckow and Schieffelin, the boom, floods, fires and strikes, later revivals, and the mine tour you can take today.

Mining is the reason this historic Old West town exists. Some visitors wonder whether Tombstone was a mining town, and it was. Silver mining is what first brought a variety of immigrants here.

So how did it all start? Here’s Tombstone’s mining history from the beginning.

Silver Discovery in Tombstone

Frederick Brunckow’s Mine

Frederick Brunckow, a German who immigrated in 1848 with a mining degree, had some mining experience in Europe. Hired by Charles Poston’s mining company, he rose in the ranks.2

In 1857 Brunckow explored the area west of what’s now Tombstone. By 1859 he had left Poston’s crew to start his own business. He hired three mining professionals and laborers from Sonora, Mexico.2

Frederick Brunckow is important in Tombstone Arizona's Mining History. Here's an early clipping showing who he is.
From the Weekly Arizonian, Thursday, April 14, 1859, page 3

They dug for silver about seven miles southwest of today’s Tombstone. Things went well until July 1860, when the laborers killed Brunckow and two of his men. Read the Brunckow mine history.

Brunckow’s silver strike became known, but few risked going into the area while Apache bands were raiding travelers and settlements.

Weekly Arizonian clipping naming Frederick Brunckow among the mines in operation in Arizona in 1859
From the Weekly Arizonian, Thursday, April 28, 1859, page 3

Ed Schieffelin

Portrait of prospector Ed Schieffelin with a long beard, wearing a hat and rough clothes, 1882
Ed Schieffelin in 1882, during a trip to the Yukon River in Alaska (unknown photographer, Public domain, via Wikimedia Commons)

Ed Schieffelin arrived at Camp Huachuca in southern Arizona Territory. He had mining experience and planned to look for minerals in the area. For protection, he asked to go along with a military crew scouting for raiding Apaches, and they agreed. Eventually he felt boxed in to one area.2

So in the summer of 1877, Schieffelin set out alone. He was warned that out there he wouldn’t find silver or gold, only his own tombstone. He remembered that warning.

He found promising geology in the hills northeast of the Brunckow mine. In the late summer of 1877 he staked his “Tombstone” claim, which was recorded that September. His next two claims were called Graveyard No. 1 and Graveyard No. 2.2 He clearly had a sense of humor.

The Library of Congress has a map of the Tombstone mining claims.

Ed needed help to work his claims. His brother Albert came to town, and they recruited Richard Gird.

The First Silver Mines

Richard Gird’s forte was mining business development. He had assaying knowledge and financial sense.

The Schieffelins and Gird used the old Brunckow mine buildings as offices, and by February 1878 they were ready.

First they struck at the Ground Hog, then the Owl Nest, then the Lucky Cuss, which also held gold. A difficult vein they traced became the Tough Nut. They knew they had found ground full of wealth.

Miners Hank Williams and Oliver Boyer came asking for prospecting advice and made an agreement with Gird’s party. Gird would assay for them and give them tips and help. In return, Gird and the Schieffelins would get a share of what they found.

The Contention Mine

Williams and Boyer filed the Grand Central claim. Gird found out and angrily accused them of hiding it. Williams said he had planned to honor the bargain, and he split off part of the Grand Central for Gird and the Schieffelins. It was suitably named the Contention.

All five men, along with Thomas E. Walker, wrote the Tombstone Mining District bylaws and submitted them to the Pima County Recorder in Tucson in early April 1878. Tombstone was on its way to becoming a town.

The Tombstone Mining District

Reports spread about the Tombstone Mining District and its silver strikes. Anson P.K. Safford, appointed governor of Arizona Territory in 1869, had Tombstone on his radar for mining ventures.

The Tombstone Mining Company and the Mills

Safford and his friend John S. Vosburg, a Tucson gunsmith, organized the Tombstone Gold and Silver Mill and Mining Company. They gathered partners, bought up claims (including the Lucky Cuss and Tough Nut), obtained water rights and built a mill on the west side of the San Pedro River.

Richard Gird became the mill’s superintendent. He married Nellie McCarty of San Francisco, and they lived in the mill bungalow overlooking Millville. Across the river, another town grew larger: Charleston.

More mines meant more mills. The Contention Mill stood on the east side of the San Pedro River, and another was the Sunset Mill. Contention City was the supply town for both.

The Contention stamp mill and its buildings beside the San Pedro River at Contention City, about 1880
The Contention Mill at Contention City, about 1880 (unknown photographer, Public domain, via Wikimedia Commons)

From 1879 to 1882, Tombstone attracted experienced mining men, and the suppliers who catered to their needs followed. The town expanded rapidly.

Vintage photo of 1880s miners in Tombstone with their mules
Miners load up their mules

Water for the Camp

Tombstone sits in the high Chihuahuan Desert, where water is scarce. If you were a new miner in town in 1879, where to get water would have been one of your first thoughts.

A few springs were nearby at Watervale, but “strong-men” guarded them and charged high prices for water. The place was suitably nicknamed “Gouge-Eye.”2

D.S. Chamberlain offered to sell miners water from his two wells at a better price, but his wells weren’t reliable.2

The Sulphuret Mine in Tombstone had a water source inside it. Its owners, the Girard Gold and Silver Mining Company, built their mill in town because of that supply. From February 11, 1882, it supplied the Tombstone Water Company.

Tombstone Becomes a Silver Mining Town

Mining brothers Samuel and Charles Calhoun had acquired 320 acres called “Goose Flats,” so they could easily pull wagons up to their Mountain Maid claim. In March 1879 Thomas J. Bidwell, a friend of Richard Gird, talked them into giving up most of their rights to Goose Flats. The Calhouns stipulated that it be surveyed as a townsite.

Two businesses were involved: the Tombstone Townsite Company and Clark, Palmer & Company. On April 19, 1879, they filed the townsite at the Land Office in Florence, and it was recorded in Pima County on April 22 as New Tombstone.

Why Is It Called Tombstone?

Many businesses were already operating. Some supplied the mines, and others catered to mine workers in their off-hours. Ranchers, cowboys and miners from outlying areas came to buy provisions, negotiate cattle deals and take care of money matters.

They usually needed a meal, and they might gamble or meet friends for a drink. Miners needed to relax after an intense working day. Tombstone’s saloons ranged from little dive corners to plush operations, and by the end of 1880 about 33 had opened. The red-light district entertained some. Those coming from outlying areas needed lodging.

So town leaders petitioned for incorporation. They considered changing the name but decided to keep Tombstone, since so many businesses already used it.

The Boom Years

From early 1880, silver mining drew people to town by the thousands. By early 1881 more than 4,000 people lived in Tombstone, far more than live there today. The mines produced, people had cash, merchants did well and homes were going up. Word of the boomtown spread across the country.

All seemed to be going well, and many came seeking mining riches. But Tombstone’s mines were easily worked. It was classed as a “soft-rock camp,” which meant less labor was needed to dig the veins.1 Only about 400 Tombstone men were normally employed as miners.

Many men came to town, ran out of money and found no work, and eventually left for other prospects. Others came looking for easy, ill-gotten gains. Silver at the mines, supply wagons and stagecoaches were all targets.

Disasters for Tombstone’s Mines

Flooded Mines

Even though Tombstone is in the desert, it has a strong but shallow water table. At a certain depth, the mines started flooding.

Silver and gold veins under water undergo chemical changes that lower the ore’s value. The mines needed pumps, which was easier said than done.

Only one type was suitable: Cornish pumps. They were ordered in November 1882 and were operating in the Contention Mine by December 11, 1883, and in the Grand Central by July 1885.

Miners were optimistic. Then, in spring 1886, fire devastated the Grand Central. Everything flammable burned, metal melted, and foul gases poured from caved-in gaps.

Water levels in the mines rose again. One idea was to tunnel into the Contention to use its pump. But the price of silver was falling, and by the end of summer 1886 half of Tombstone’s mining workforce had been let go.

The 1884 Strike and the Bank Failure

During the flooding troubles, mine management planned to cut pay from $4 a day to $3. Tombstone’s miners went on strike.

Then on May 10, 1884, the Hudson bank in Tucson shut down. Its Tombstone branch was in the Vizina & Cook building at 5th and Allen. The teller closed up and headed for Tucson to find out what was happening. Meanwhile, striking miners gathered at the bank door, anxious about their own money, and a rumor started that the cashier had made off with it.

The sheriff stepped in and headed off possible vigilante action. The miners did lose their money, but because the Hudson bank failed, not because of anything the teller did.

Newspaper item describing how the bank failure affected the Tombstone branch in 1884
From the Mohave County Miner, Sunday, May 18, 1884, page 2

The strike dragged on with hard feelings all around, and there were some militant incidents near the mines. A military company from Fort Huachuca was sent to check on the situation. On September 1, 1884, the Miners’ Union gave in and accepted $3 a day, ending the strike.

Revival and Decline

The owners of the Contention and Grand Central mines decided to mine deeper. On May 1, 1887, they formed an Arizona corporation, the Grand Central Mining Company.

Men were hired to clean up the Grand Central. They opened a new shaft and repaired the machinery, and more were hired to work the company’s neighboring mines, about 300 employees in all.

Newspaper description of the Lucky Cuss mine in Tombstone, 1887
From the Tombstone Weekly Epitaph, Saturday, October 1, 1887, page 4

New mines opened, older ones did well, and things looked up. But in 1890 silver prices dropped again. Then fire dealt Tombstone mining a near-fatal blow. After midnight on Christmas 1891, flames shot out of the Contention shaft, fed by the draft, and spread to all the mine buildings.

With just one water pipe for the firefighters, it was hopeless. The mine burned out and lay in ruins. Contention management stopped all mining, and the metal scrap was shipped to Mexico.

Of the two big local mining employers, one was just getting by and the other was gone.

Some miners staked their own claims and got by, selling their ore to the Tucson Sampling Works, whose agent came to town now and then.

The Tombstone Mill and Mining Company still employed some miners. They went on strike on May 16, 1896, for a 50-cent raise, and after nine days the company agreed and the men went back to work. The town squeaked by with the price of silver.

But most businesses had left town, and mine workers left for other mines, such as those in Bisbee and the Black Diamond. The 1890 census counted 1,875 people in Tombstone, and by 1900 only 646 were left.

Vintage photo of a mule team hauling ore at Tombstone's Bunker Hill mine
A mule team carries ore at the Bunker Hill mine

Tombstone Consolidated Mines Company

E.B. Gage and W.F. Staunton wanted to revive mining in town. In May 1900 they formed the Tombstone Consolidated Mining Company and bought 96 good claims. Their plan was to bring in equipment, solve the water problem and get the mines running.

Frank Murphy, an experienced railroader, was a major player. His goal was a rail line into Tombstone for efficient delivery of supplies and equipment, something the town had hoped for for years.

Murphy got Phelps Dodge to sponsor a branch line from Fairbank. Work began on July 29, 1902. Built with second-hand rail, it reached town and was ready on March 25, 1903, with two boxcars at the end of 4th Street as a temporary station. The line was in use by April 1903 and finished by January 1906.

Advanced pumping equipment was installed, and a crew was hired to run the pumps and make steam.

Tombstone Consolidated’s success inspired others to return to mining. In November 1906 a rise in the price of silver also helped, and the miners got a raise.

The Good Enough Cave-In and Hard Times

At 1 p.m. on April 21, 1907, Charles Gage hitched his horse near the southeast corner of 5th and Toughnut Streets. The horse started stumbling, and as Gage tried to see what was wrong, the horse and wagon disappeared into a hole. Gage was right on the edge.

The ground had been the roof of a stope in the Good Enough Mine, only about 12 inches thick, and today the site is part of the Good Enough Mine tour. Amazingly, the horse wasn’t hurt and was brought out. The hole was fenced and became a sight to see. Some thought the new train had weakened the crust.

A photograph of the Good Enough mine cave-in in Tombstone
The roof of the Good Enough Mine caved in

Good times never seemed to last. Later in 1907 the stock market crashed. Large companies couldn’t meet their payrolls, and unemployment surged.

The next year silver dropped more than 3 cents an ounce. Tombstone Consolidated shut three mine operations and laid off 50 miners, and fire broke out again at the Lucky Cuss. But the company recovered by the end of 1908 with the help of superintendent James Macia.

A Consolidated Tombstone Gold and Silver Mining Company stock certificate
A Consolidated Tombstone Gold and Silver Mining Company stock certificate of 1883

The problems weren’t over:

  • Keeping water out of the mines was a constant fight.
  • Pump maintenance was difficult, and timely repairs and replacement parts could be hard to get.
  • Tombstone Consolidated’s financing company, the Development Company of America, mismanaged funds. That came out when liens were filed for three months of back pay.

To solve it, the company reorganized through bankruptcy. F.M. Murphy put $40,000 into an account to make sure employees got their back pay and Tombstone businesses were paid. The bankruptcy took two years to finalize, and Tombstone Consolidated was offered for sale. Phelps Dodge bought it for $500,000 on July 8, 1914.

The new owners got to work soon, bringing in their own management and hiring 300 men for mining jobs. The U.S. economy wasn’t booming, so Phelps Dodge developed its purchase at a slow, steady pace. By the middle of 1915 it had hired 60 more workers.

World War I and the Silver Market

War broke out in Europe in August 1914, and the U.S. entered it in April 1917. The American mining industry was nervous about the war’s effects. Copper mines, including Bisbee’s, laid off workers until demand returned in mid-1915.

Manganese was important during World War I, and western silver mines often have manganese-bearing silver ore. Tombstone became the prime U.S. producer, and by early 1917 Phelps Dodge had 600 employees in Tombstone.

The company followed the course of the war. Seeing peace coming, it shut down most large-scale production and stopped entirely on April 1, 1918. Many employees left to find mining jobs elsewhere.

Phelps Dodge leased out smaller gold and silver mines on its property, and mining men from the surrounding area rushed to get leases. But 1918 was a slump year.

Then the U.S. government stepped into the silver market with the Pittman Act that April. For several years the government bought silver from U.S. mines, and silver prices soared.

Those good times ended too. The Pittman Act purchases ended on May 31, 1923, and silver’s value dipped right away. Tombstone’s leaseholders hung on.

Visitors Start to Come

Tombstone settled into a quiet period, and the remaining miners earned enough to get by.

Arizona voters approved statewide prohibition in 1914, and when it took effect the next year it ended the town’s saloon business.

After World War I, government road programs brought more car traffic to Tombstone, and Allen Street was paved in December 1922.

A coast-to-coast route called the “Broadway of America” was promoted. Its western part was U.S. 80, which ran through Tombstone on Fremont Street. Travelers on the Broadway of America stopped to see Tombstone, and slowly the town gained mining sites for tourists:

  • The caved-in Good Enough Mine, called “The Million Dollar Stope”
  • The Schieffelin Monument, the grave of Ed Schieffelin, the miner who founded the town
Ed Schieffelin Monument, a tall stone cairn with a plaque, under cloudy sky
The Schieffelin Monument, Ed Schieffelin’s grave, west of town off Allen Street

Then came Thursday, October 24, 1929, Black Thursday, the day the American stock market crashed.

The Depression, World War II and the Last Mining

The crash hit Arizona hard, especially the prices of the metals mined in southeastern Arizona: silver, gold and copper. Prices kept falling and credit dried up. Millions had lost their jobs by the end of 1930, and Tombstone was no different.

Phelps Dodge cut production and mine working days. At the end of 1931 it shut down Tombstone mining entirely, including the leased mines.

Miners couldn’t pay rent or support their families. Single men left town. Family men gathered on downtown street corners, passing time and wondering what to do.

The Red Cross helped, especially families and children. Relief agencies formed, and Phelps Dodge contributed to fundraising and helped some long-time employees’ families. Still, many were hungry and malnourished. Children’s health suffered, and some people stole food where they could.

Spurts and Sputters

In early 1932 a new mining corporation started operating. The San Diego, Last Chance, Grand Central and Empire claims restarted, and by summer 150 miners were working.

In 1939 the government reentered the silver market with a law setting the price just under 71 cents an ounce, good for two years with possible renewal. That kept things on an even keel, though fires at two Tombstone claims were a further setback.

World War II hurt the local economy, and the 1940 census counted only 822 people in Tombstone. This time manganese wasn’t needed, but lead was. It was mined in three places:

  1. Nearby, at Charleston
  2. Five miles south of Tombstone, off Charleston Road
  3. East of Tombstone, at the Extension Mine in Emerald Gulch

Zinc was mined in Bisbee, southeast of Tombstone. Local miners received military deferments to work these mines.

The Open Pit

After the war the federal government helped again. Manganese was wanted once more, and a program paid part of the cost of exploration and bought ore for five years. But six more fires plagued the claims over the years.

From 1950 until 1990 there were scattered mining attempts. Tombstone’s pioneering Escapule family formed the Escapule Mining Association and other companies to mine in Tombstone.

Dustin “Dusty” Escapule, as general manager of Tombstone Exploration Inc., started an open pit as “economical mining.” It consumed a hill south of Tombstone and the old Grand Central Mine.

By the late 1970s, some mining professionals felt the Tombstone area was exhausted. Some ore remained, but it wasn’t worth the investment to get it, which is why open-pit mining was seen as the method of the future.

It didn’t turn out that way. Costs, pollution risks and government paperwork made it unworkable, and by 1990 Tombstone mining had essentially come to an end.

Tombstone’s Mining History for Visitors

Tombstone has the look of a Wild West town, which is often what visitors come for. But do they sense the true history of why and how the town got started?

We truly appreciate our visitors. For a long time now, tourism has replaced mining as the town’s livelihood. People who live here know that, make their living from it and work hard to help visitors have a good experience.

We also like helping visitors get a good feel for Tombstone’s history, including mining. Some local museums help with that. For the best look at the town’s beginnings and related history, we recommend the Tombstone mine tour.

The Tombstone Mine Tour

Tourists in hard hats inside a chamber of the Good Enough silver mine on the Tombstone mine tour
Underground on the Tombstone mine tour

For details, see the Good Enough Mine section of our Tombstone tours guide.

References

1 Daily Nugget, December 2, 1880.

2 Bailey, L.R. (2004). Tombstone, Arizona: “Too tough to die.” The rise, fall, and resurrection of a silver camp; 1878 to 1990. Westernlore Press, Tucson, Arizona. A prime general resource for all historic details not otherwise noted.

Newspaper clippings courtesy of our subscription to newspapers.com.

No comments yet

Leave a comment

Comments are read by a real person before they appear, usually within a day. Your email is never published.