Virgil Earp was the second child of Nicholas and Virginia Ann (Cooksey) Earp. He was born on July 18, 1843 in Hartford Kentucky. Named as Virgil Walter Earp. The family moved to Monmouth, Illinois. Then to Pella Iowa in 1850, when Virgil was 7 years old. That's really where he spent his childhood. There his father had the family farm.
When 16 years old, Virgil met Magdalena C. Rysdam. A Dutch immigrant from Utrecht, Netherlands, she was nicknamed Ellen. 8 months older than Virgil, she was born October 25, 1842. The two of them eloped. It's believed they were in either Oskaloosa or Knoxville Iowa to get married on September 21, 1861.1-6 The marriage is unconfirmed by documentation. It's possible it was never legal. There's some evidence they gave false names of Walter Earp and Ellen Donahoo.7
During Virgil Earp's time in the war, word reached home. About midway in his service some said he'd been injured and killed. When Ellen received this notification, she believed she was now a war widow. She likely felt it would be difficult on her own, with a child. It's felt her father, along with Virgil's father, approved of her believing this rumor.
In early 1864 Ellen married a Pella immigrant Dutchman named John Van Rossum. Soon thereafter they joined a wagon-train trek bound for the Pacific Northwest. Many Dutch immigrants headed there to get away from the war. They wanted to avoid subjugation to the draft and its problems. Her husband, John, became one of the trek leaders for this almost 2000 mile trip. She helped by driving one of the wagons over the Oregon Trail. They arrived in Oregon City six months and many dangers later.5
Virgil Earp, alive and well, received his army discharge on June 26, 1865. He went back to Pella Iowa to return to his wife and child. But he found they were no longer there. He probably heard why they left, and he didn't pursue them. The Earps had also left, trekking by wagon train to San Bernardino California in 1864. Father Nicholas Earp rented a farm there on the Santa Ana River.
Virgil traveled to reunite with his parents and siblings. He noticed younger brother Wyatt was restless and didn't want to help on the farm. He took Wyatt and they both began teamster work for a local company.8
Virgil drove the stagecoach. He taught 17-year-old Wyatt the ropes of the business, as a "swamper." Wyatt rode the shot-gun seat, helped with loads, and gave Virgil a break in driving. They went on a route to Los Angeles, to Prescott AZ, and sometimes to Salt Lake City.7 Some time after that they went to Wyoming to work on building the railroad.
At some point Virgil and Wyatt went their separate ways. Wyatt continued on with his own adventures. Virgil decided to go back to Pella Iowa. Virgil stayed in Pella awhile, working at a few jobs.
Virgil's father had moved the family again in 1868. Farming was not working out, as none of the sons were interested in that line of work. Nicholas moved the family to Lamar Missouri.
Virgil Earp decided to rejoin his father and the family in Missouri. There he met a French immigrant 10 years his junior. Nicholas Earp had become the Justice of the Peace in Lamar.
He officiated the ceremony between Virgil Earp and 17 year-old Rosella Dragoo on May 30, 1870. There's no further word of Rosella. It's possible her parents objected to the marriage. It may have been annulled. Or it could be she succumbed to a deadly illness of the day. We don't really know, as no further records citing her have been located.
In the 1870s, Virgil left Lamar MO. He ended up in Council Bluffs Iowa. There he met a waitress named Alvira Packingham Sullivan. She was called "Allie." It seemed they were meant to be - they stayed together for life.
Allie was born in 1874 in Florence Nebraska. She was 25 when Virgil came to town, and they met. Soon they began traveling around together.11 Around mid 1876 they were in Dodge City Kansas. Wyatt Earp was in town there, as an assistant Marshall. Virgil went to hook up with Wyatt, touch base with him. The Earp brothers often tried to stay near each other. Virgil was deputized by Wyatt there for a short time.
Virgil Earp moved with Allie to the Village of Prescott AZ in July 1877.9 He worked a few jobs while living there. He got a job as a mail carrier, and then worked in a sawmill. An incident in town gave Virgil an opportunity to be immediately deputized as a lawman.
[See Call-Out Box ->]
As a result of this incident, Virgil became well known in the village of Prescott. In early March 1878, the Village Council met. They gave Virgil a position of authority, verging on a law enforcer - as their Night Watchman.
Patterson, Caldwell & Levally, a Prescott freight company also offered him a job as a driver. He took them up on that, and made stagecoach runs for them. This job enabled his meeting Arizona Territory Secretary of State, John J. Gosper. Another notable passenger was Crawley P. Dake.11 These meetings eventually would bring him to Tombstone AZ.
On November 1, 1878, Virgil Earp announced his candidacy for Prescott Village Constable. It was noted in the local paper. The Arizona Weekly Miner of Prescott supported his election.
The results of the election were published on November 8, 1878. Three men ran for Constable. Virgil Earp beat the closest competitor by just over 100 votes. He then resigned his position as the Night Watchman, and the town Council appointed a new one. Virgil and Allie seemed to be settling in to their life in Prescott Arizona.
Virgil Earp's brothers were scattered about the West at the end of 1878. They wrote to each other, discussing possibilities as the year 1879 progressed. Virgil had noted the action in Tombstone, Arizona - the discovery of silver. This new southern Arizona town was on the move!
Crawley P. Dake was Arizona Territory U.S. Marshal. Stage robberies in southern Arizona were a severe problem in the late 1880s. He wasn't getting much requested Federal help with his plans for solving the problem. Essentially being ignored, he began doing things his own way. In the Autumn of 1879, he offered Virgil Earp the job of Deputy United States Marshal.12
Virgil was ready for this move, if Allie wasn't quite. Some of these bothersome issues were reported in Prescott's local newspaper, the Arizona Weekly Miner:
Virgil informed his brothers he was prepared to move to Tombstone AZ. James and his wife Bessie came to Virgil's home. Also arriving there that autumn were Wyatt with Mattie Blaylock, and Doc Holliday with Big Nose Kate. All the brothers looked forward to new opportunities in Tombstone.
Virgil Earp accepted the appointment for the position of Deputy U.S. Marshal on November 27, 1879. In an interview, Virgil himself said, "I went from Prescott to Tombstone as Deputy United States Marshal."9 All the group left Prescott and arrived in Tombstone the first part of December. Only Doc Holliday and Big Nose Kate did not travel with them. They stayed behind at that time for local gambling opportunity.
Virgil and Allie found a house on the Southwest corner of Fremont and 1st Street. Wyatt found a location just down from them. Virgil busied himself getting settled in town.
He had some tasks as Deputy U.S. Marshal, none too serious at first. In July of 1880, there was an anti-Chinese mob in town. He notified Dake of the possibility of a riot occurring.16
Dake had asked him to handle problems with marauding cow-boys in the area. In the late 1800s the word "cow-boy" applied to ranch hands who roamed the range. They grabbed cattle, especially those near the border. They were accused of changing brands and then selling them. Virgil anticipated working to solve this problem.
But Virgil wasn't paid very well. Officially, he was called on intermittently to help county and city administrators. An incident in late October, 1880 led Virgil to try to expand his law opportunity.
City Marshal Fred White was shot by Curly Bill Brocius. White admitted before he died that it was accidental. He expired a few days later from his gut wound. Virgil was immediately appointed to fill in as the acting Tombstone City Marshal. This was a much better financial position for him.13 Virgil decided to run for the office. They held a special election on November 13th. Ben Sippy was his opponent. Virgil lost by 52 votes.
Although Sippy won, 7 months later he requested a Leave of Absence. It was suspicious that he never returned! Hmmm - it was found he left some fishy financial circumstances behind.
At that time Mayor John Clum appointed Virgil Earp as the acting City Marshal. Then a serious fire scorched much of Tombstone's business area. [Read More>] Virgil's popularity soared as he patrolled the streets with his Winchester. He prevented lot jumpers from illegally taking land. Virgil Earp was promoted to Tombstone's Chief of Police on June 28, 1881. His pay was now a reliable $150/month.11
Virgil's first actions were investigating stage robberies. One in particular happened on March 15, 1881. A well-known freight employee and a passenger were shot dead. Plus the strong-box was stolen.
The suspects were a group of cow-boys. Virgil gathered together a posse which included his brothers and Doc Holliday. They went after the offenders and secured some clues. They were never able to make an arrest.11
In April of 1881, Tombstone city fathers enacted a new ordinance. It prohibited deadly weapons in town, unless you were a law officer. To be fair the original law was a little confusing. It was difficult to enforce the way it was written, and not particularly popular. That was one contributing factor to the enmity between the Earps and the area cow-boys.
Virgil mentioned the first encounter he had with the cow-boys. He said it "was when they stole a band of government mules from Camp Ruckner" [sic]. Virgil got a posse and went to the McLaury ranch where they saw the suspected mules. Tense words were exchanged there, but no arrests made.9
When in town, various groups of cow-boys often had conflicts with the law. They were blowing off steam, drinking heavily. Behavior like that can irritate some citizens - and law enforcement. The Earps became well known to some of the cow-boys, and vice-versa. In late October of 1881, the irritation between these two factions headed to a deadly duel.
Cow-boys Tom McLaury and Ike Clanton came into town on Tuesday, October 25, 1881. They needed to take care of some errands. Afterward they wanted to stay over, have a meal, gamble and drink. They got a room at the Grand Hotel. Recently when talkative Ike was in town, he'd been grumbling about his dislike of the Earps. That included this day. In fact, the more he drank, the more intense his complaints became.
That evening Ike went to a saloon to gamble and drink. Wyatt, Morgan and Virgil Earp, plus Doc Holliday came in. Doc began an argument with Ike. Doc told Ike to go get armed, since he wasn't. The Earps broke up the fight, and Wyatt took Doc back to his room at Fly's Photography Studio.
An odd combination of men started a poker game - Ike Clanton, Virgil Earp, Tom McLaury, John Behan, and one other guy. They played all night, until about 7 in the morning. As Virgil was leaving Ike told him that Doc was going to have to fight.
Virgil had been trying to keep things calm in most interactions. He was always one who tried reasoning as a first tactic.11 As Virgil headed home to get some sleep, Ike was still irate. He said to Virgil how he aimed to kill Doc Holliday. Virgil felt it was just drunk talk. He told him to go home to sleep it off. That he didn't want to hear anymore talk like that, after all he was the law.
But Ike didn't stop. He continued around town, barking his dislike of the Earps and Doc Holliday. Lots of town-folk heard his rantings, his threats against their lives.
When Virgil woke up, he heard from friends about Ike's actions. He felt it necessary to find him, be sure he wasn't armed, and disarm him if needed.
Eventually Wyatt, Morgan and Virgil Earp encountered the Clantons and McLaury brothers. They all gathered in a vacant lot next to the O.K. Corral. Historical accounts are unsure who began the shooting. But it was all over very quickly. Ike Clanton ran off and was unharmed. But his brother Billy was dead. The McLaurys were dead. Wyatt was not hit. Doc Holliday was barely grazed. Morgan was shot into his shoulder and upper back. Virgil got it in his upper leg. It was all over with 3 dead and 3 injured in a matter of less than a minute.
The town of Tombstone split over who was at fault. The funeral for the 3 cow-boys drew about 3000 people from the Tombstone District. A procession with the coffin carriage followed the Tombstone Brass Band. The coffins held a banner: "Murdered in the Streets of Tombstone." About 300 people, wagons and horses followed behind as part of the cortege in support. They made their way to Boot Hill Cemetery for burial.11
While Virgil was recuperating, Ike Clanton filed murder charges against him, Wyatt, Morgan and Doc. Wyatt and Doc were jailed, Virgil was suspended as Police Chief. The initial hearing by Judge Spicer determined the Earps and Holliday acted justifiably within the law, if maybe unwisely. In two more weeks a grand jury gave a similar outcome. They dropped the charges against Virgil Earp, his brothers Wyatt and Morgan, and on Doc Holliday.
Judge Spicer received an anonymous threatening letter. He responded to the threat with a letter in the Tombstone Epitaph. The Epitaph's editor, John Clum, was then shot at by some unknown person!
Virgil was in the Oriental Saloon that evening. A heated discussion developed between Oriental manager, Milton Joyce and Virgil. Joyce had worked together with the Earps before. Especially with Wyatt. But he definitely didn't like Doc Holliday. Lately he'd had some touchy situations with the Earp group.
Joyce said he thought Virgil was behind the attack on John Clum. Virgil became incensed and slapped Milton Joyce! Joyce then left the barroom, backing out. He said to Virgil sarcastically, that he didn't want to end up in the usual Earp doom situation - shot in the back.11
The Earps knew the dislike they felt throughout town had heightened. Plus the danger to their lives had increased. They moved from their homes into the Cosmopolitan Hotel.
On December 28, 1881, Virgil Earp was walking home on Allen Street. He was between the Oriental and the Crystal Palace Saloons. Shots rang out, coming from a second story area which was being constructed. This was above the Bucket of Blood Saloon (present day: Longhorn Restaurant). Virgil was hit by the gunfire, which severely injured his left arm.
On March 18, 1882 Morgan and Wyatt Earp went for a game of pool at Campbell & Hatch's on Allen Street. Two bullets sped through the back door from an alley. The first bullet hit Morgan - a fatal shot. The second shot came close to Wyatt's head, but missed and entered a wall. Morgan died a little later, with family members by his side.
Morgan's body was shipped back to Colton California. Virgil and Allie knew it was time to leave town. They accompanied the remaining Earp women and boarded the train to Colton.
Virgil and Allie stayed in Colton with the family. During this time Virgil began getting treatment for his arm. For about two years he traveled up to San Francisco to get specialized medical care.11
Virgil obtained a private security guard job for the Southern Pacific Railroad. They had a territory battle with a division of the Atchison, Topeka and Santa Fe. He had his gun ready in the engineer's cab. He was there for prevention of forward track by their competitor. That was - until the courts ruled.1
Next he opened a detective agency in early 1886. In his spare time, he also began to gamble.1 He and Allie moved into their own home on West H Street (it's still there).11 Virgil's father, Nicholas Earp was very well known in the area by then. He was the manager of the Gem Saloon. In 1884 he was elected Colton's Justice of the Peace.11 With the local Earp reputation, Virgil was elected as Colton city constable on July 2, 1886. With that, he disbanded the detective agency. In the next year's election he became City Marshal.11
Soon it was apparent that position wasn't what he was used to. It paid $75 a month. He mostly dealt with drunks and vagrants. He ended up using his own funds to pay for needed repairs and materials. He even had to dig and clear the jail's sewer line himself! He gave his resignation in March 1889.1
To make money at first Virgil began arranging boxing matches in a larger city just Northeast - San Bernardino. He'd had a little experience doing that together with Wyatt in their early days.11 He applied for a pension because of the chronic problems suffered from his work injuries. It was approved, and he was granted $12/month. For steady work, he began managing a gambling hall in 1890.11
Their next move was to San Luis Obispo, North - near the coast. Virgil and Allie were following horse racing. He began placing bets at the track there.11 It wasn't as good as they thought it would be - so they moved on.
Next it was to Vanderbilt California in April 1893.11 It was a gold camp close to the Nevada state line. He opened a saloon there, called it Earp's Hall. Upstairs was a large room for dances, boxing matches, and even Sunday church services. People took to him, liking his quiet, but friendly personality. Yet when he ran for their constable position in 1894, he didn't win.1
Wyatt and his wife Josie were headed to the gold-mining town, Cripple Creek Colorado. Virgil and Allie headed there to meet up with them. They planned to open a saloon.
But Cripple Creek had already met its hey-day and was booming. It had many saloons already. Did it need another? No!11 Virgil soon realized this. So he took Allie and they left for Arizona again. They remembered how they had liked it there.
Virgil and Allie went to the town they'd first resided in - Prescott, AZ. They settled on a ranch in Kirkland Valley, south of town.1 This time Virgil thought he'd try mining.
He talked to W.H. Harlon, and together they leased the Grizzly Mine. They were working the mine, looking for the gold ore one day. It was November 7, 1896. Suddenly there was a cave-in! Virgil was knocked out. Rock and dirt fell on top of him. He was badly injured with a hip dislocation, contusions and lacerations all over. Plus a large, bleeding head wound. He needed crutches for some time.11
As he recovered, he focused more on his ranch. He also helped out with law work in town in Prescott. When needed, they would deputize him.11
In late 1898 Virgil received a letter in the mail. It came from Oregon. It was from a woman who'd read in newspapers about the O.K. Corral shootout. Of course it mentioned Virgil Earp, and stated his current location.
The letter was from a Mrs. Levi Law. In this letter she asked: was he the Virgil Earp who had married Ellen Rysdam in 1861 in Iowa? She said if it was true, then she was Nellie Jane, his now grown daughter!1
Virgil and Allie were amazed and thrilled! They began a correspondence. Nellie Jane planned a trip to visit them in Arizona. But her daughter came down with pneumonia, which made the trip impossible.
Instead, in April 1899 Virgil went to Portland OR to see his daughter and granddaughter. He stayed for two weeks.14 Virgil found out he had two other grandchildren, and a great-grandchild on the way.11 The following year Nellie Jane was able to get to Arizona for a visit.1
Virgil was still popular enough in Prescott to get a nomination for Sheriff in 1900. He was the Republican nominee for Yavapai County. But before the election, he withdrew for some reason.1
Virgil often returned to Colton to visit his family. He began to sell his farm animals in 1902. He had property in the area which he also began to sell off.11 He probably thought of returning to Colton to live.
The small town had an ordinance that only allowed one saloon. Virgil got involved in a petition to repeal this law. The churches were against a repeal. But the council did repeal it. Only the replacement law just allowed one more saloon. And that liquor license went to T.J. Tuschman.1 This outcome didn't align with Virgil's plans. So instead he and Allie moved to Goldfield Nevada in 1904.11
Why Goldfield now? A new, booming gold-mining town. Virgil Earp was in no shape at this time in his life to go into mining. He didn't have much in extra funds for investment into a business venture. He had his reliable pension. Allie could earn some money with her sewing. He got a job as an enforcer - some called the position a special officer - maybe a bouncer, really, at a local casino in town - the National Club.11
With his notable experience, though, he got back into law enforcement. He became the Deputy Sheriff of Esmeralda County on January 26, 1905. He served under Sheriff J.F. Bradley.11
Virgil began serving as the Deputy Sheriff. But within a few months he began to feel ill. It was pneumonia. He tried to fight it, using treatments of the time. He seemed to feel better for a while, but then had a set-back. In October 1905 he was seriously ill. He went into St. Mary's County Hospital, on Euclid Avenue in Goldfield.15
That's where he succumbed to pneumonia on October 19, 1905. He was 63 years old.11 Allie was at his side, holding his hand in his last moments.15
Allie sent a telegram to inform Virgil's daughter, Nellie Jane. She said her father had passed on. She advised that if she wanted to have him she needed to act fast, because Wyatt aimed to claim his body.
Nellie Jane's son-in-law, Alex Bertrand, went to Goldfield. He acted in her behalf to bring back Virgil Earp in his coffin. Virgil was buried in the Bertrand family plot. That's located in River View Cemetery in Portland Oregon. It's the state of Oregon's oldest non-profit cemetery, originating in 1882.14
Allie returned to Colton California to the home that she and Virgil owned. There she spent the rest of her days. She lived to be 98 years old.11
As a lawman Virgil Earp normally tried reason first, then went to force only when necessary. He used deadly action only as a last resort. Through the years many people commented on his personality. They usually had kind or admirable things to say about him. In the Tombstone area, many still held bitter opinions of the Earps, including Virgil.
In the present day, it's difficult to know how to judge someone who has been dead many years. There are always two sides to a story. We can be sure Virgil Earp had some faults. Yet, he was probably trying to do the best he could in law enforcement. Everyone who reads his story, and studies his history will have to make their own conclusions.
1 Paul, J.S. & Carlisle, G. (2002, February). Frontier lawman Virgil Earp. Wild West. Retrieved from www.historynet.com/frontier-lawman-virgil-earp.htm
2 Simkin, J. (2014, August). Virgil Earp. Spartus Educational Ltd. Retrieved from spartacus-educational.com/WWearpV.htm
3 Friedman, R. (1997). Tracking down Oregon. Caldwell, ID: The Caxton Printers Ltd.
4 Ganstra, P. (2010, July 25). Earps were shooting long before the OK corral. Civil War Primer retrieved from www.civilwarprimer.com/2010/07/earps-were-shooting-long-before-the-ok-corral/
5 Beltman, B.W. (December 1997). Nineteenth century Dutch migrants extraordinaire on the prairie-plains. Retrieved from www.aadas.nl/sites/default/files/proceedings/1997_12_Beltman.pdf
6 Hopper, P. (n.d.). Of Roseville, CA. Via San Bernardino County Archives. 777 East Rialto Ave, San Bernardino, CA
7 Clavin, T. (2017). Dodge City: Wyatt Earp, Bat Masterson, and the wickedest town in the American West. New York: St. Martin's Press.
8 Cataldo, N.R. (n.d.). The Earp clan: The Southern California years. As re-edited on the City of San Bernardino History Index page: Wyatt Earp in San Bernardino. Retrieved from www.ci.san-bernardino.ca.us/about/history/wyatt_earp.asp
9 Palmquist, R.F. (1982, May). Arizona affairs: An interview with Virgil Earp. Real West Magazine. Retrieved from web.archive.org/web/20090423122018/http://www.angelfire.com/co4/earpgang/interviewtwo.html
10 The Weekly Arizona Miner (Friday, 19 October, 1877). The victims of their own folly. Prescott, Arizona. Retrieved from www.newspapers.com/image/49592834
11 Charles River Editors (n.d.) Legends of the West: Virgil Earp and Morgan Earp. Harvard and MIT Alumni.
12 Ball, L. D. (Autumn 1973). Pioneer Lawman: Crawley P. Dake and law enforcement on the Southwestern frontier. The Journal of Arizona History. Arizona Historical Society. 14 (3), pp 243–256. JSTOR 41695121.
13 Marks, P. M. (1996). And die in the West: The story of O.K. Corral gunfight. Norman, OK: University of Oklahoma Press. ISBN 978-0-8061-2888-7.
14 John, F.J.D. (2010, September 27). Why legendary Old West lawman Virgil Earp is buried in Oregon. Offbeat Oregon History. Retrieved at offbeatoregon.com/H1009d_virgil-earp-buried-in-portland.html
15 Goldfield Historic Walking Tour Booklet (2013, August). The Goldfield Historical Society, a 501c.3 Non Profit organization. 4th Edition. Retrieved from goldfieldhistoricalsociety.com/Goldfield_2013_Booklet_Web.pdf
16 The Weekly Arizona Miner (1880, July 30). The Chinese Must Go, p3; Prescott AZ.