Tombstone, Arizona · Open daily, no entry fee · Most shops close around 5 p.m.Contact
Tombstone Travel Tips
Engraving of cowboys resting by a campfire as a mounted scout rides up and calls to them
Historical Figures

Crawley Dake

Crawley P. Dake, U.S. marshal for Arizona Territory from 1878 to 1882, deputized Virgil and Wyatt Earp during the Cowboy troubles in Tombstone.

Crawley P. Dake was the U.S. marshal for Arizona Territory from 1878 to 1882, the years when the Cowboy troubles around Tombstone came to a head. He was the man who made Virgil Earp, and later Wyatt Earp, deputy U.S. marshals.

His support of the Earps hasn’t always served his reputation well. Here’s his story, from a Civil War cavalry officer to the marshal who had the Earps’ backs.

Early life and the Civil War

Cabinet card portrait of Crawley Dake, a bearded man in a dark suit
A cabinet card of Crawley Dake, taken in Edmond, Oklahoma Territory.

Crawley Dake was born in Canada, in Kemptville, Ontario, on September 15, 1836. When he was very young, his family crossed to the other side of the St. Lawrence River and settled in Ogdensburg, New York, where he grew up.

At 19 he moved to Romeo, Michigan, where he opened a store, ran for office, married and had a son. During the Civil War he raised a company and became an officer in the 5th Michigan Cavalry. A serious leg wound led to his retirement as a major in August 1864.

Old photograph of the ferry crossing the St. Lawrence River between Prescott, Ontario, and Ogdensburg, New York
The Prescott and Ogdensburg ferry across the St. Lawrence, about 1878, near Dake’s boyhood home.

Back home after the war, he served as chief deputy marshal in Detroit. His government and military service likely developed his organizational skills. As author Larry D. Ball put it, he wasn’t “always in the midst of action…. [but] made the plans and chose good men to carry them out.” He also became a good friend of Senator Zachariah Chandler.

Uniformed veterans of the 5th Michigan Cavalry posed with an American flag
A reunion of 5th Michigan Cavalry veterans, date unknown (Library of Congress). Dake isn’t in this photo.

U.S. marshal for Arizona Territory

Settlers in the Southwest were increasingly disturbed by lawlessness, which grew especially bad in the 1870s. In the late 1870s and into the 1880s the territory counted at least 36 stage robberies, many allegedly by Cowboys in Cochise County and around Tombstone. People feared the trend would drive away business and endanger citizens.

1878 Yuma newspaper item about a stage robbery and Marshal Dake
Arizona Sentinel, Yuma, Saturday, August 24, 1878, page 3.
Portrait of U.S. Marshal Crawley P. Dake
Marshal Crawley P. Dake, about 1878.

Crawley P. Dake was appointed U.S. marshal for Arizona Territory on June 12, 1878. Territorial Governor John P. Hoyt objected, but Michigan’s delegation in Washington prevailed. Dake arrived in Prescott, then the territorial capital, and went to work.

Working with little help from Washington

Dake found the Washington bureaucracy hard to deal with. He asked for money to track the so-called Cowboy outlaws, and Washington was slow to send it.

Telegram to Marshal Dake printed on the front page of the Arizona Citizen in 1879
Arizona Citizen, Tucson, Friday, July 25, 1879, front page.

Dake appointed deputies across the territory. One of them, on November 27, 1879, was Virgil Earp, an appointment that brought the Earps to Tombstone. The Posse Comitatus Act of 1878 barred the use of Army troops in posses without congressional authorization, so Dake turned to deputizing civilian posses instead.

The governors of Sonora, Mexico, and Arizona began cooperating on extradition of cross-border criminals. It wasn’t popular with everyone, and it didn’t always work.

Dake made use of the latest technology of the day. He used the telegraph and published his telegrams in the newspapers for transparency. He issued wanted posters with whatever rewards he could find a budget for. Within two years he had accomplished a lot with little outside help, even putting in his own money.

Wooden building housing the U.S. Marshal's office on North Cortez Street in Prescott
The U.S. Marshal’s office on North Cortez Street, Prescott, in May 1877, shortly before Dake arrived.

The O.K. Corral gunfight and its aftermath

Appointing Virgil Earp as a deputy U.S. marshal had repercussions. Virgil was at odds with the men known as the Cowboys, and around half the local population was at odds with Virgil and his brothers. But as his boss, Crawley Dake had Virgil’s back.

After the gunfight at the O.K. Corral, retribution came for Virgil. In December 1881 he was shot at as he crossed the intersection of Fifth and Allen Streets. The shots came from the upper story of a building where the Longhorn restaurant stands today. His left arm was hit and permanently damaged.

Dake had a decision to make. Wyatt Earp put himself forward to take over Virgil’s job as deputy U.S. marshal, and Dake agreed and appointed him. Was that wise? Many didn’t think so at the time, and many still don’t. His support of the Earps hasn’t served Dake’s story well with some.

Harper’s Weekly and “The Cow-boys of Arizona”

During the Cowboy conflict, Harper’s Weekly published an engraving with an editorial called “The Cow-boys of Arizona.” The Tombstone Epitaph took strong exception to it, with good reason. It had errors, common in those times, including quotes from former acting governor John Gosper that the Cowboys numbered 50 at most, and a claim that Cochise County was named after a whitish stone found in local silver mines.

Engraving of cowboys resting by a campfire as a mounted scout rides up and calls to them
“Cow-boys of Arizona: Roused by a Scout,” drawn by W.W. Rogers from a Frederic Remington sketch, Harper’s Weekly, 1882 (Beinecke Library, public domain, via Wikimedia Commons)

The Epitaph replied: “the name of our justly celebrated county – we can forgive the late acting governor for… misrepresentations upon this subject…. the county derived its name from the once famous Apache warrior named Cochise, whose stronghold was in the Dragoon Mountains some twelve miles to the north of this city…. how easy it is for people to be mistaken.”

The lengthy editorial went on to defend Arizona, Cochise County and Tombstone, and also Crawley Dake, as this excerpt shows:

Excerpt from an 1882 Tombstone Epitaph editorial defending Marshal Dake
Tombstone Epitaph, Monday, March 13, 1882, page 5.

Leaving office and later years

Dake’s superiors had hoped he would settle the Cowboy conflict. Instead it ended in the gunfight, the reprisals and Wyatt’s vendetta ride. But was he given the support he needed, and was it all on him?

Dake was replaced as U.S. marshal on July 17, 1882. A few years later he was charged with misusing funds while in office, and he was cleared.

He stayed in Prescott, living on Marina Street, and went back to merchandising while continuing to dabble in mining. By late 1888 illness from his old war wound was overtaking him, and Crawley Phillips Dake died on April 9, 1890.

1890 Prescott newspaper report of Crawley Dake's death
Weekly Journal Miner, Prescott, April 16, 1890.

He’s buried in Citizens Cemetery in Prescott.

Map locating Citizens Cemetery in Prescott, Arizona
Citizens Cemetery in Prescott.

Places like Tombstone make us curious about the people who roamed the area and the Old West, and about the true story behind them. We enjoy sharing what we find, and we hope you’ll visit the places where they spent their time. For more on federal lawmen of the era, see our article on the deputy U.S. marshal.

No comments yet

Leave a comment

Comments are read by a real person before they appear, usually within a day. Your email is never published.