The shootout at the OK Corral in 1881 is the event that put Tombstone on the map. At the time, Tombstone was a thriving silver town of several thousand people, and it was growing daily.
This is our quick, inside look at the background to that famous gun battle, the Gunfight at the O.K. Corral. Put yourself in 1881 and see what was happening in town.
Tombstone Before the Shootout
Tombstone’s first attraction was silver. Ed Schieffelin gets the credit for the find and the name: his first claim, filed in September 1877, was called Tombstone. The town itself was laid out in March 1879. The census taker who walked the camp in June 1880 counted about 2,170 residents. He didn’t really count everyone, though, and the town was growing fast.

Who Was Already in Town
Within two years many more people had moved to Tombstone to seek their fortune. Several of the soon-to-be-famous players in the shootout were already in the area:
- Five Earp brothers, and their women, were residents.
- Doc Holliday came to Tombstone in 1880.
- John Behan was a deputy sheriff and later the Cochise County sheriff.
- Johnny Ringo was already living in the area.
- Frank and Tom McLaury were ranching in the San Pedro River Valley.
- Curly Bill Brocius had been around since 1878.
- Newman Hayes “Old Man” Clanton lived with his extended family in an adobe house at Lewis Springs, south of Charleston: Ike, Billy and Phineas, plus his two daughters and their husbands.
- In early 1879 Ike Clanton opened a boarding house and restaurant in nearby Millville.
- Photographer Camillus S. Fly and his wife Mollie opened their photography gallery in December 1879.
Easy Pickings
Several things about the area help explain why the 1881 shootout happened, and why its story lived on. Men looking for dishonest gain found easy pickings:
- Mining leftovers were fairly easy to snatch and sell.
- Trade caravans out of Mexico were targeted for their goods.
- Cattle roaming the open range through southeastern Arizona and northern Mexico attracted stockmen (cow-boys) who lived on the edge of the law.
- The Civil War left bitterness in the hearts of many who headed west.
Tombstone Becomes a Town
Tombstone began with a townsite claim covering the two areas where miners had settled near their claims, called “Upper Town” and “Goose Flats.” The Tombstone Townsite Company recorded with Pima County on April 22, 1879. Lots were sold, a post office opened, a justice of the peace was appointed, and an interim mayor and councilmen were elected.1 None of those first officials could have guessed that a shootout would keep the town famous.
Townspeople generally lined up with one of the two political parties, and so did the two local newspapers. The Tombstone Epitaph‘s editorials took the Republican view. Tombstone’s first newspaper, the Nugget, held the Democrats’ outlook.1
The Earps and the Law in Tombstone
Fred White became Tombstone’s marshal. Virgil Earp had been appointed deputy U.S. marshal for eastern Pima County, and he arrived in Tombstone with his wife in December 1879.
Within months all the Earp brothers were there. They made their living from mining claims, bartending, gambling and law enforcement. Wyatt Earp was appointed a deputy sheriff on July 27, 1880, but political complications meant he held the post for only a few months.
John H. Behan replaced Wyatt as deputy, which created an undercurrent of conflict between the two. Behan was also a bartender, gambler and horse racer, and he was often seen with local women.
Guns and Problems
In April 1880 the Tombstone Common Council passed an ordinance to prevent violence in town. Concealed firearms, knives or other weapons couldn’t be carried within village limits without the mayor’s permit.1 But it was hard to enforce.
In the early hours of October 28, 1880, some unruly stockmen, including Curly Bill Brocius, had been drinking all night. These men were often called the Cochise County Cow-boys. They walked down the middle of Allen Street firing their guns into the air.2
Town Marshal Fred White was nearby and approached the group. He said, “This won’t go, boys,” identified himself and confronted Curly Bill. White said “give that up” and grabbed the gun barrel. The gun went off, and White was shot in the gut.3
Wyatt Earp ran up and “buffaloed” Curly Bill, knocking him down with his pistol. Brocius and the others were arrested on the weapons charge. Fred White died two days later, but first he cleared Curly Bill, saying the shooting was accidental.
The council made Virgil Earp interim marshal. He ran for the permanent position but lost to the more popular Ben Sippy. Local people were very upset about the Fred White incident.
A New Gun Law in 1881
Tombstone became a city in 1881, with a regular police department. The gun ordinance was reworded to ban carrying any weapon, concealed or not, without a permit issued for good reason.1
Enforcement was still vague. You could carry your weapon while going to your lodging, and again on your way out of town. Judging from later reports, the change didn’t do much to reduce gunplay in town.
Other Shootings in the News
The territorial newspapers of 1880 were full of shooting stories from Tombstone. A few examples:




The Road to the Shootout
Wyatt and a Cow-boy’s Secret Pact
In 1881 a rise in stage robberies worried the lawmen. Area stockmen, the Cow-boys, including the Clantons, were suspected of being involved.
Behan organized posses to track the robbers, and the Earps joined in. In mid-1881 Marshal Sippy took a leave of absence and never returned. Virgil Earp was asked to take the job, and he kept his deputy U.S. marshal position as well.
Wyatt Earp still had his eye on a prominent lawman’s job. Tombstone was now the seat of the newly created Cochise County, and Wyatt wanted to run for county sheriff in 1882. He thought of a way to win publicity and popularity: he’d bring the stage robbers to justice.
He worked on the idea of using informants and spoke with Cow-boy Ike Clanton. Would Ike secretly give him information that led to the robbers? Wyatt would then quietly hand Ike the reward money. All Wyatt wanted was the credit for the catch.
Ike agreed, and they worked out a plan. It came to nothing in the end, because the robbers were already dead.
Cow-boys in Town
Ike then grew wary of Wyatt. He felt Wyatt no longer had any reason to keep their deal quiet, and he became paranoid about it.
On October 25, 1881, Ike Clanton and Tom McLaury drove their wagon into Tombstone. They went to the butcher shop and finished their errands. Then it was on to entertainment: saloons and gambling for the rest of the day, into the evening and past midnight.
Around midnight Ike ran into Doc Holliday and Morgan Earp at the Alhambra Saloon. Neither man was friendly toward him, then or ever, and both had been drinking.
Ike’s Ire

Doc and Ike had a mean-spirited exchange. Doc told Ike to go arm himself, since he wasn’t heeled. Ike came back with a gun at his side, but sat down to play poker in the Occidental Saloon with Tom McLaury, Virgil Earp, John Behan and another, unnamed man.
The game broke up around dawn. Ike left complaining to Virgil about Doc: “The damned son-of-a-bitch has got to fight.” Virgil tried to calm him down. He said he was going to get some sleep and didn’t want Ike causing trouble.4
Ike started roaming town, armed, complaining about how Doc Holliday and the Earps had treated him and saying he was ready for a fight. Word of his antics spread quickly.
When Virgil woke up and heard what Ike was doing, he called on his brothers Morgan and Wyatt for help. They found Ike on Fourth Street between Allen and Fremont. Coming up behind him, Virgil hit him on the side of the head with his gun, took his weapons and brought him to court.
Before Judge Wallace, his head oozing blood, Ike was fined $25 plus court costs. All the while he cursed the Earps under his breath. Then he left.
He Ain’t Heavy, He’s My Brother
That same morning Billy Clanton and Frank McLaury, brothers of Ike and Tom, rode into town. At the Grand Hotel they had a pleasant exchange with Doc Holliday.
They heard about Ike’s court appearance and went to find him. They met up at Spangenberg’s gun shop on Fourth Street, where they made purchases. Frank’s horse was standing on the sidewalk, another violation of the law. Wyatt came along and moved it into the street. When the brothers came out there was an ugly exchange of words, but no action.
It looked as if the Clantons and McLaurys were getting ready to leave town, so even though they were armed, they weren’t arrested. They left the shop and walked through Dunbar’s Stable toward the O.K. Corral.
By mid-afternoon they had met up with another Cow-boy, Billy Claiborne, a friend of Billy Clanton. They all gathered in a vacant lot just west of the O.K. Corral, talking about the morning’s events and getting their horses ready to ride out.

The Shootout at the OK Corral
Virgil, Wyatt and Morgan Earp, with Doc Holliday, walked west along Fremont Street. Virgil meant to make sure the Cow-boys really were leaving town. In his own words, he went “to take away their arms, intimidate them, and again show them who was boss.”5
John Behan tried to stop the Earps, but they walked past him into the vacant lot off Fremont Street, just west of C.S. Fly’s boarding house and photo gallery. Virgil approached the Cow-boys, and Billy Claiborne made a quick exit. Virgil said, “Boys, throw up your hands. I want your guns.” Someone else, many say Wyatt, was heard to say, “You sons-of-a-bitches, you have been looking for a fight, and now you can have it.”5

The shooting started almost at once, and it’s hard to say who fired first. About 30 shots were fired in about 30 seconds. Frank and Tom McLaury and Billy Clanton were mortally wounded. Morgan Earp was hit across the top of his back, Virgil was shot in the calf, and Doc was grazed on the hip. Wyatt was untouched. Ike Clanton, who had started it all, ran away unharmed.
About 300 people followed the coffins of Frank and Tom McLaury and Billy Clanton to Boothill Cemetery, and many more watched from the sidewalks. The McLaury brothers were buried in the same grave, with Billy Clanton beside them. The town was divided over who was at fault.


Divided Opinions After the Shootout
The local newspapers reflected the split. The Epitaph felt the Earps, led by Virgil as marshal, had acted within the law. The Nugget saw them as guilty of murder and wanted them arrested.
A three-day investigation led to City Marshal Virgil Earp’s suspension. Ike Clanton filed a murder complaint against the Earps and Holliday. Wyatt and Doc were arrested. Morgan and Virgil weren’t served, because they were bedridden with their wounds.
The hearings began, and much of the testimony blamed the Earps and Holliday. On November 30, 1881, Judge Wells Spicer gave his ruling. He found the killings were “a necessary act, done in the discharge of an official duty.”5 A grand jury agreed.
The Nugget and the Arizona Daily Star published editorials criticizing the decision, and the town stayed about evenly divided. The aftermath of the shootout was only beginning.

Meet the Players
Knowing the players helps you understand where they were coming from. Our life stories cover their personalities, backgrounds and experiences, and what they did during the shootout:
Who Was to Blame?
People still argue about the shootout. Here are the questions we hear most:
- Were the Cow-boys entirely at fault?
- Did the Earps and Doc Holliday start it?
- Did both sides share some of the blame?
- Was the law so vague that the circumstances were to blame?
- Was no one really to blame?
References
1 Bailey, L.R. (2004). Too tough to die: The rise, fall, and resurrection of a silver camp; 1878 to 1990. Westernlore Press: Tucson, AZ. Prime reference for anything not specifically cited.
2 Daily Arizona Citizen (1880, Oct. 29). Shooting at Tombstone. P. 2. As reported in the Tombstone Epitaph, Oct. 28, 1880. Tucson, AZ.
3 Tombstone Epitaph (1880, Oct. 29). Tombstone, Arizona.
4 Virgil Earp deposition, Turner, O.K. Corral Inquest
5 Bailey, L.R. (1999). A Tale of the unkilled. The life, times, and writings of Wells W. Spicer. Tucson, AZ: Westernlore Press


No comments yet