Tombstone, Arizona · Open daily, no entry fee · Most shops close around 5 p.m.Contact
Tombstone Travel Tips
Frederic Remington painting of two cowboys on galloping horses catching a comrade who is falling from his horse
Wild West History

Cochise County Cowboys

Who the Cochise County Cowboys really were, from Curly Bill and the Clantons to the border rustling that reached the President. Red sashes? No.

The Cochise County Cowboys were publicized around the country during the 1880s. The Wild West drew adventurers, pioneers, miners and cattle ranchers, all looking for opportunity on the frontier. Mexican families had been here for generations, many of them raised in ranching in the tradition of the vaqueros.

What was it about the Cochise County “Cow-boys” that attracted so much attention? They earned their reputation through newspaper stories, and eventually caught the eye of the U.S. President in Washington. To understand how, it helps to start with Tombstone’s beginnings.

How Tombstone Began

The first settler

In the 1860s Frederick Brunckow mined just southwest of today’s city of Tombstone. He was the first non-native person to establish a settlement in the area. Read the Brunckow Mine history.

Ed Schieffelin and the name “Tombstone”

Ed Schieffelin was a mining man interested in the country around Camp Huachuca. He asked to go along with a military force on patrol. He liked the troop’s protection, but he was soon frustrated by the restraint on going his own way.2

Desert landscape of the Tombstone Hills with ocotillo, boulders and mesquite under cumulus clouds
The Tombstone Hills, where Ed Schieffelin prospected in 1877

Schieffelin decided to explore on his own and search for mineral deposits in the Tombstone Hills. As he set off, a soldier told him that out there by himself he would find no silver or gold. Instead, “you’ll find your tombstone.”

He remembered that warning when he discovered silver and began mining just south of today’s town. In August 1877 he named his first claim “Tombstone.” His next two mines he named Graveyard No. 1 and Graveyard No. 2.2 He had a sense of humor. The town that grew up nearby took its name from his mine. We cover the whole story in Tombstone’s mining history.

Arizona Weekly Citizen August 1879 clipping about Ed Schieffelin
From Tucson’s Arizona Weekly Citizen, Friday, August 1, 1879, front page

People poured into town, and tradespeople followed to fill their needs: mercantiles, restaurants, corrals (including the O.K. Corral) and saloons.

Silver mining drew people from early 1880 on. With only about 400 mining jobs available, not everyone found work. Some came for ill-gotten gains instead. Silver in the mine areas, supply wagons and stagecoaches were all targets. The Cochise County cowboys soon acquired a reputation for stagecoach hold-ups.

Old-time miner's camp with a tent
Newcomers: mining men often lived in tents

Other entrepreneurs supplied the ranching outfits surrounding Tombstone. Their ranch hands, the cowboys most of us picture, came into town to buy feed, sell cattle, deposit money and run errands. They often stayed overnight, had a meal and sometimes visited the red light district.

A common entertainment was a wagering game such as faro or poker, usually in a saloon. Many of these men came armed with guns or knives. Then alcohol entered the mix. The combination often led to violence, and some of the cowboy personalities roaming Cochise County were definitely up for that.

Lowry Ranch roundup, 1883
Noted as a round-up at the Lowry Ranch, 1883

What Did It Mean to Be Called a Cowboy?

In 1878 the term “cow boy” described roughly the person we think of today. The Dodge City Times described him as one of the many men who drove cattle to town, “to herd and care for them.” They sometimes got into trouble and spent a night in jail.26

Dodge City Times news item from 1878 describing cowboys
Dodge City Times, Saturday, June 22, 1878, page 4

In southeastern Arizona the word took on a darker meaning. The Chiricahua Apache Reservation there was abolished in 1877, and cattlemen started grazing their herds on the land. The herds attracted rustlers, and some of the cattlemen were the rustlers. The term “cow-boys” began to be applied to them.

Cowboys and Tombstone’s Problem With Violence

The newly formed Tombstone city government passed Ordinance Number 9 on April 12, 1880. To prevent violence, concealed weapons, specifically guns, rifles and knives, could not be carried into town without a permit. Anyone entering town had to put up such weapons.

A Phoenix newspaper quotes a Tucson paper describing another murder in Tombstone, July 9, 1879
From Phoenix: Weekly Republican, Wednesday, July 9, 1879, page 3

The ordinance was hard to enforce and openly flouted by the lawless, particularly those becoming known as Cochise County cowboys. Tombstone’s reputation as a Wild West town had begun. One resident wrote, “Our town is getting a pretty hard reputation. Men killed every few days, besides numerous pullings and firings of pistols and fist fights.”1

The killing of Marshal Fred White

One incident that really set people against the “Cow Boys” happened in October 1880. Curly Bill Brocius was drinking hard at Thomas Corrigan’s saloon with stockmen Frank Patterson, Ed Collins and Dick Lloyd, plus three local miners.2 After midnight they were out on Allen Street shooting pistols into the air. Marshal Fred White came up and asked for their weapons, grabbing Curly Bill’s gun by the barrel.

Wyatt Earp ran up too. The gun went off and White was shot in the gut. Wyatt took the gun and slammed Bill over the head with it. Marshal White died hours later.

Los Angeles Herald article from October 1880 on how Tombstone's city marshal was killed
From the Los Angeles Herald, Friday, October 29, 1880, page 2

The scene was portrayed in the 1993 Tombstone movie, if not quite accurately. Were these cowboys really identified by red sashes? Sorry to disappoint, but no.

Comment on the 1880 Tombstone gun ordinance from the Arizona Daily Star
Tucson’s Arizona Daily Star, Tuesday, November 2, 1880, page 3, quoting the Tombstone Nugget

The stagecoach robbery of March 1881

In March 1881 another episode outraged locals. A stagecoach was robbed and the driver and one passenger were killed. Cochise County cowboys were the immediate suspects. A posse gathered and headed out right away. Among them were Pima County Sheriff Bob Paul, Wells Fargo agent Marshal Williams, “Deputy U.S. Marshal V. W. Earp and his two brothers [and] Sheriff John H. Behan, of Cochise County.”3

Sacramento's Record Union describes the posse that set out in 1881
Section of a Record Union article, Saturday, March 19, 1881, page 4

The Cochise County cowboys drew attention throughout the country. Three of them robbed the safe in Springer & Hacke’s store in Charleston. Deputy Sheriff Belle’s posse tracked them and shot two, Burns and Clubfoot Jack. A Nashville paper ran the story on its front page on April 22, 1881.4

The Fort Wayne Gazette reported that a gang of twenty cowboys killed the Hazlett brothers, murderers themselves, surprising them at a card game in a saloon. No one was ever held to account. Pittsburgh and York, Pennsylvania papers carried the story too.5,6,7 The sheer number of cowboy stories drew attention toward Cochise County and Arizona.

Who Led the Cochise County Cowboys?

A local incident got further recognition in the East. The trouble began on the cattle ranches of the Sulphur Springs Valley, near the former Chiricahua Reservation. Cattle thieves worked both sides of the international border, and Cochise County cowboys were known or alleged to be involved. Names you will recognize from that country include Johnny Ringo, Curly Bill Brocius, the Clantons, and Frank and Tom McLaury.8

So who was the leader? The “Cow Boys” of southern Arizona were not a formal organization, so there was no official leader. Some feel it was Old Man Clanton. Others think Johnny Ringo took the lead. Many of the cowboys came and went. The question is still open.

Five riders in cowboy hats on horseback on a Cochise County ranch trail at golden hour with mountains behind
Ranch country in Cochise County. Working cowboys still ride here

Guadalupe Canyon

Mexican ranchers chased some rustlers in late May 1881 and killed three before the cowboys got back into Cochise County. The cowboys planned revenge for their friends. That August, seven cowboys including Old Man Clanton were driving cattle to Tombstone through Guadalupe Canyon, near the border in New Mexico, when they were attacked early in the morning. Five, Clanton among them, were killed. Two escaped.9

Grave marker of Newman Haynes Clanton, Old Man Clanton, in Boothill Graveyard, Tombstone
Old Man Clanton’s grave in Tombstone’s Boothill. He was killed in Guadalupe Canyon in August 1881 (DrStew82, CC BY-SA 4.0, via Wikimedia Commons)

Word of the incident spread, with two cowboy eyewitness accounts, and it fed people’s fears. Yet there is a credible theory that it was not Mexican retaliation for cattle theft but an Earp posse attack. Crawley Dake, U.S. Marshal for Arizona Territory, had reason to rein in the cowboys. He wanted to prevent an international incident. Dake’s surviving telegrams lend support to this theory.8

A Philadelphia news item from The Times explains the consequences of continued cowboy trouble near the Arizona border
From Philadelphia’s Times, Friday, August 19, 1881, front page

Newspapers around the country reported border incidents throughout August 1881, including several versions of the Guadalupe Canyon attack. The result was public alarm and concern in both governments.

Article from the Waukesha Daily Freeman of August 25, 1881, explaining the border arrangements
Waukesha Daily Freeman, Waukesha, Wisconsin, Thursday, August 25, 1881, page 2

The Gunfight and Its Aftermath

All of this led up to the famous gunfight in Tombstone, in a vacant lot next to the O.K. Corral, between several Cochise County cowboys on one side and the Earps and Doc Holliday on the other.

The shootout was mentioned in newspapers throughout the country. Yet it was not a particular sensation at the time, just another part of the Cochise County cowboy problem.

O.K. Corral shootout headline in the 1881 Green Bay Press Gazette
From the Green Bay Press Gazette, Friday, October 28, 1881, front page

The bigger focus came decades later, when the town needed to improve its economy or risk becoming a ghost town. Television and the movies helped, basing shows and films on this infamous shootout.

Poster showing the three cowboys who died in the O.K. Corral gunfight
The O.K. Corral gunfight in Tombstone history: the three cowboys who died

The aftermath of the gunfight brought further repercussions, especially through Ike Clanton. He drummed up support for revenge against the Earps and Holliday. This led to more killings, including that of Morgan Earp. Tombstone politics and the continuing legal consequences divided people. Eventually the Earps and Doc left Arizona, and the remaining Clantons moved away from Cochise County.

1882 news clipping on Cochise County cowboys versus the Earps
Arizona Weekly Citizen front page, Sunday, January 29, 1882, quoting Tombstone’s Nugget

The Cowboy Problem Reaches Washington

Cowboy activity was still a problem in Cochise County. An Epitaph article titled Cowboys and Their Sympathizers brought it to light. It quoted Acting Governor Gosper: “The people of Tombstone and Cochise County…, have grossly neglected self-government until the lazy and lawless element of society have undertaken to prey upon the more industrial and honorable classes…”10

The governor estimated the number of Cochise County cowboys at “twenty-five to fifty,” whom he called “skilled cattle thieves and highway robbers.” He said bands of cowboys roamed territory-wide, meaning Arizona and New Mexico, and that others, under a law-abiding pretense, cooperated with them for profit.10

The acting governor sent a letter to Washington. President Arthur brought it to the attention of Congress and recommended amending the Posse Comitatus Act to allow the military to help territorial authorities establish law and order.11

A bill was prepared.12 Many in Cochise County, and in Arizona generally, did not feel the cowboys needed federal oversight. Congress did not take it further.27

Hicksville News report on Cochise County cowboys, 1882
From The Hicksville News (Ohio), Thursday, May 11, 1882, page 3

On May 13, 1882, the Epitaph published a letter from a Charleston resident signing as “Argonaut” that regretted the President’s proclamation. It called the “howling about the cowboy and preaching up a state of terrorism here” false and useless. Those who derided the cattlemen, it said, did not realize they were “honorable, high-minded men in business.” Argonaut divided cowboys into two categories:

  • The respectable ones, who worked for their living.
  • Those not deserving much respect, such as the ones in town gambling, living off others’ earnings and worse.13

For a while attention centered on this fight with the legislature rather than on cattle rustling. Cowboys and their friends protested the federal government’s meddling in territorial problems.14 By early the next year, Cochise County was still known as the “county of cow-boys.”15,16

Yuma news article describing southeastern Arizona as the county of cowboys
From Yuma’s Arizona Sentinel, Saturday, January 27, 1883, page 3

The End of the Cowboy Era

A February 1883 letter printed in a Tucson newspaper described cross-border rustling. The writer, “Red Rock,” said horses and mules stolen from ranches were tracked over the Sonoran border, while cattle taken from Mexico turned up in Charleston and Tombstone with “American cowboys.”17

The next month the Tucson Citizen commended the governor of New Mexico for his handling of that territory’s cowboy problem, saying that if Arizona had taken the same actions “during the cow-boy days in Arizona, we would have been much better off.”18

Through the rest of 1883, reports of robbery and horse and cattle smuggling continued in southern Arizona, expanding into Graham County, though less intensely than the year before. The national reputation lived on, with headlines like “The Land of Murder” and “More of the Diversions of the Hell-Hounds of Arizona.” Tucson newspapers started complaining. The Citizen wrote, “The cowboy element is dwindling down to small numbers and in a few months they will be numbered among the things of the past.”19

Early the next year Tucson papers quoted the San Francisco Chronicle approvingly. It recognized that Arizona had stepped up law enforcement and that the Cochise County cowboys were now law-abiding cattlemen: “Arizona authorities are determined to stamp out the lawlessness…. the era of the cowboy has passed…”20 The Arizona Citizen called on the local immigration bureau to publicize the fact.21

By the summer of 1884 even a Prescott paper noted that cowboy gun violence had diminished.22 A Phoenix item told of cowboys who stole freight and then came back to pay for it.23 An engagement announcement in the Epitaph described the groom-to-be as “a prominent ex-cowboy.”24

By 1887 cattle crossing from Mexico into the U.S. had to be inspected.25 Crime remained a problem to some degree, but the cowboy issue had dwindled to almost nothing.

Cochise County Cowboys Today

Wyatt Earp Days banner over Allen Street with the O.K. Corral sign, re-enactors and a mule-drawn wagon
Re-enactors on Allen Street during Wyatt Earp Days

Today visitors can check out the O.K. Corral, the vintage saloons and the other attractions, and take in the street gunfights and local Western shows. The performers love portraying the Cochise County cowboys. Now it is all in fun. For what is on when you visit, see our current Tombstone events guide.

We hope visitors will also appreciate the authentic history. Tombstone is not an amusement park or a pretend Wild West town. It is a real city, with a history from the 1800s that included these cowboy troubles. Those who live here take pride in that history and like to portray it.

References

1 Parsons, George W. (1996). A tenderfoot in Tombstone. The private journal of George Whitwell Parsons: The turbulent years, 1880-82, p 72, Westernlore Press, Tucson AZ.

2 Bailey, L.R. (2004). Tombstone, Arizona: “Too tough to die” The rise, fall, and resurrection of a silver camp; 1878 to 1990. Westernlore Press, Tucson, Arizona. A prime general resource for anything without notation.

3 The Record Union (1881, March 19). The stage robbery – Fears of Disaster, p. 4. Sacramento, California.

4 The Tennessean (1881, April 22) Arizona Robbers, p. 1. Nashville TN.

5 Fort Wayne Daily Gazette (1881, June 23). Particulars of a murder, p. 1. Indiana.

6 Pittsburgh Daily Post (1881, June 23). Killed by cow boys, p 1. Pennsylvania.

7 York Daily (1881, June 24). Killed by cow boys, p. 4. Pennsylvania.

8 Traywick, BT (1996). The Clantons of Tombstone. Tombstone AZ: Red Marie’s Bookstore & Los Angeles: We Print It Inc.

9 The Arizona Weekly Star (1881, Aug. 25). Border warfare. Tucson, Arizona.

10 Tombstone Weekly Epitaph (1882, Feb. 13). Cowboys and their sympathizers, p. 5. Arizona.

11 Arizona Weekly Citizen (1882, Feb. 27). Relief for Arizona, p. 2. Tucson, Arizona.

12 Harrisburg Telegraph (1882, May 4). House, p. 1. Pennsylvania.

13 Tombstone Weekly Epitaph (1882, May 13) From Charleston, p. 2. Arizona.

14 Arizona Weekly Citizen (1882, May 14). Telegraph: Special to Citizen, p. 2. Tucson, AZ.

15 Perrysburg Journal (1882, May 19). General news summary: Interesting home and foreign news – Domestic, p. 1. Ohio.

16 Arizona Weekly Citizen (1882, Sept. 10). P. 2. Tucson.

17 Arizona Daily Star (1883, Feb. 18). Harshaw, p. 4. Tucson.

18 Arizona Weekly Citizen (1883, March 4). P. 2. Tucson.

19 Arizona Weekly Citizen (1883, Sept. 29). Coast notes, p. 2. Tucson.

20 The Arizona Sentinel (1883, Dec. 15). P. 2. Yuma.

21 Arizona Weekly Citizen (1884, Feb. 23) P. 1. Tucson.

22 Mohave County Miner (1884, June 15) P. 1. Mineral Park, Arizona.

23 Weekly Republican (1884, July 31). From Saturday’s daily, p. 4. Phoenix, Arizona.

24 Daily Gazette (1885, Feb. 9). A dismal town for a honeymoon, p. 2. Fort Wayne Indiana.

25 Tombstone Daily Epitaph (1887, March 5). Inspector’s notice, p. 4. Arizona.

26 Gazette, Sterling (1878, June 22). Doings at Dodge, p. 4. Correspondent (Rice Co.), Dodge City Times. Kansas.

27 Name Redacted (2018, Nov. 6). The Posse Comitatus Act and related matters: The use of the military to execute civilian law. Congressional Research Service. Retrieved from everycrsreport.com/files/20181106_R42659_a9b336fa9e37e2302a210433da31f27bd3287cdd.pdf

Newspaper clippings thanks to our subscription at https://www.newspapers.com/

No comments yet

Leave a comment

Comments are read by a real person before they appear, usually within a day. Your email is never published.